backenduserlandcom:
How to hook into UserLand.Com through XML, XML-RPC and SOAP.

 
XML

About

Home

RSS

OPML

XML-RPC

SOAP



Members
Join Now
Login

   

Re: Comment on post 321

Author:   Fredrik Lundh  
Posted: 6/30/2003; 2:01:05 PM
Topic: My political FAQ for RSS 2.0
Msg #: 332 (in response to 322)
Prev/Next: 331/333
Reads: 13233

Dave, the funkiness issue has been explained many times, and should be obvious for anyone who's done enough file format work: if you use extensions, don't use extensions instead of the corresponding baseline elements.

A feed is "funky" if it uses an extension to provide information that can be expressed by baseline elements, without providing the corresponding baseline element.

Or in other words, a feed is "funky" if it deliberately hides information it has access to from applications that only implement the baseline. Providers should strive to maximize interoperability, also with future applications, instead of just looking at what "most current clients" do.

And IIRC/BTW/FWIW, Ben's already said that he's aware of the problem, and that they're going to fix the "MT funkiness" in an upcoming release. All in order to give clients a choice, and maximize interoperability.




Last update: Monday, June 30, 2003 at 2:01:05 PM Pacific.

This is a Manila site.